When a Payer Uses AI on Your ABA Authorization: What New State Laws Require
Informational only; not legal, billing or clinical advice. Law summaries are based on the enacted bill text as of Nov. 10, 2026. Check your state, plan type and contract before acting.
Most of what we write here is about AI on the clinic side: drafting notes, building treatment plans, tracking authorizations. But AI is showing up on the other side of the table too. Payers and utilization review companies are using automation to sort, approve and route prior authorization requests. If your reauthorization comes back cut or denied, it's fair to ask how that decision was made.
Two states have now put that question into law.
Alabama: in effect since Oct. 1, 2026
Alabama's SB 63 took effect on October 1, 2026. It applies to health benefit plans in the state and to the utilization review teams or contractors working for them. Under the enacted text, a plan that uses AI to make medical-necessity decisions on prior authorization requests must:
- Base those decisions on the enrollee's medical history, the clinical circumstances the requesting provider presents, and other clinical information in the record.
- Certify each year to the Alabama Department of Insurance that the AI does not rely on a group dataset to make determinations and does not discriminate.
- Make a prominent written disclosure about its use of AI in utilization review in its policies and procedures.
The part that matters most for BCBAs: any decision to deny, delay or modify a request based on medical necessity must be made by a licensed physician or other health care professional who is competent to evaluate the AI's recommendation in light of that person's specific clinical situation. "Modify" is worth noticing, because in ABA the common outcome isn't a flat denial. It's fewer hours than you asked for.
Colorado: scheduled for Jan. 1, 2027
Colorado's HB26-1139 was approved June 2, 2026, and is set to take effect January 1, 2027. It covers carriers, utilization review organizations working for them, and, for mental and behavioral health services, Medicaid managed care entities and behavioral health administrative services organizations that use AI in utilization review.
Under the act, the AI must base its determination on the individual's own clinical history and circumstances, not solely on group data. Covered organizations must keep audit logs and file written disclosures with the state describing where AI is used and what human oversight applies. A denial based in whole or in part on medical necessity can't be issued solely on AI output without review and approval by a licensed clinician, physician or other regulated professional competent to evaluate the specific clinical issues.
What Medicaid plans say they do
In its June 2026 report on automation in Medicaid prior authorization, MACPAC, the congressional advisory commission on Medicaid, found that some states and plans use automation to approve requests without human review. The states and plans it interviewed said their tools do not deny requests and that denials are reviewed by a human. MACPAC also found that no federal regulation explicitly addresses automation in Medicaid prior authorization.
So the honest picture is that you usually can't see whether AI touched your request. What you can control is whether your request makes the individual case impossible to miss.
What to do when hours come back cut
- Read the reason closely. Note whether it's a medical-necessity decision or an administrative one, like a missing form. They call for different fixes.
- Ask who made the decision. Request the reviewer's credentials and the criteria used. In Alabama, and in Colorado once its law takes effect, a medical-necessity denial has to have a qualified human behind it.
- Request a peer-to-peer if the plan offers one, and come ready to talk about this learner, not ABA in general.
- Answer with individual data. These laws hinge on the enrollee's own history and circumstances. Graphs, goal-level progress, the barriers you're addressing and why the requested hours fit those goals are exactly that information.
- Watch the clock. HealthCare.gov says that for the plans it describes, an internal appeal must be filed within 180 days of the denial notice, and you can ask for an external review if the denial stands. Medicaid and employer plans can follow different rules, so check yours.
Where clinic-side AI fits
AI tools can help you pull together a progress summary or a first draft of an appeal letter faster, as long as the tool is covered by your clinic's agreements and the BCBA writes the clinical argument. A templated appeal reads like group data. A request built on one child's outcomes reads like the individualized review these laws now ask payers to do.
Compare authorization and documentation tools in the ABA AI Tools directory.
Sources
- https://alison.legislature.state.al.us/files/pdf/SearchableInstruments/2026RS/SB63-enr.pdf
- https://leg.colorado.gov/laws/session-laws/HB26-1139/325/download
- https://www.macpac.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/Chapter-2-Automation-in-Medicaid-Prior-Authorization.pdf
- https://www.healthcare.gov/appeal-insurance-company-decision/internal-appeals/
More from the blog
- AI Note Auditors for ABA: What They Check, and What Still Needs a BCBA
- AI Can Draft the Assessment Report. You Still Own the Evaluation.
- SOC 2, BAAs and Badges: How to Read an AI Vendor's Security Claims Before Your ABA Clinic Signs
- An Autism Center Replaced Its Supervisor With AI. Here Is What AI Can't Take Over in RBT Supervision
Informational only; not legal, clinical or compliance advice. Vendor HIPAA/BAA statements are as published by the vendors and are not verified by us. Sponsorship never changes our rankings. Corrections: admin@gtbehaviorbolts.com.